Bombay High Court Upholds Right to Feed Stray Dogs: Landmark Victory with Aditya Pratap Representing Respondents

Public Matters Stray Dogs

Posted by: Aditya Pratap Law Offices on 2024-07-19

---

In a significant judgment dated March 20, 2023, the Bombay High Court ruled in favor of permitting the feeding of stray dogs within Seawoods Estates Limited (SEL) premises, addressing a divisive issue among residents and animal welfare advocates. The decision highlights the importance of animal rights and humane treatment, establishing a precedent for similar cases nationwide.

SEL, a company representing flat owners, sought to restrict stray dog feeding, citing concerns over nuisance and resident safety. However, advocates including Aditya Pratap and Abha Singh argued fervently that caring for strays is both a moral imperative and protected under law.

 

Arguments Presented

The case, brought before the court by SEL, a collective of flat owners and purchasers, aimed to restrict the feeding of stray dogs within their residential complex. Petitioners argued that the presence of strays posed hygiene risks and safety hazards, particularly for vulnerable residents such as children and the elderly.

In defense of stray dog feeding, advocates Abha Singh and Aditya Pratap highlighted the moral and legal obligations to treat animals humanely. They emphasized the necessity of feeding programs as part of broader efforts to manage stray populations through sterilization initiatives, citing guidelines from the Animal Welfare Board of India (AWBI) that mandate such practices.

The court's ruling favored the respondents, endorsing the continuation of feeding activities within designated areas of SEL premises. Emphasizing a balanced approach, the judgment recognized the rights of animals while addressing resident concerns about safety and cleanliness. Crucially, the court proposed the establishment of a specialized Animal Welfare Committee (AWC) comprising representatives from both SEL and animal welfare advocates. This committee is tasked with overseeing feeding programs, ensuring compliance with regulations, and promptly addressing any issues arising from these initiatives.

Abha Singh’s extensive experience in animal rights advocacy provided a robust legal foundation, reinforcing arguments with established laws and ethical principles. Aditya Pratap’s strategic advocacy underscored the broader implications of the ruling for animal welfare practices in residential settings, highlighting the importance of compassion and responsible management of stray populations.

 

Implications of the Judgment

The recent judgment by the Bombay High Court has underscored the legal obligation to care for stray animals, setting a precedent for similar cases nationwide. The court's decision permits the feeding of stray dogs within residential complexes like Seawoods Estates Limited (SEL), involving both residents and animal welfare advocates in overseeing these efforts. This cooperative approach aims to address concerns while promoting humane treatment and balanced community coexistence. The ruling reflects India's evolving recognition of animal rights, ensuring a compassionate approach to managing stray populations and fostering a progressive society.